Echo - reviewed by Diana Foster

Echo by Pamela Munoz Ryan

Reviewed by Diana Foster

Echo, the newest novel by author Pam Munoz Ryan, is an eloquent and heartfelt novel that intertwines three stories during the time leading up to World War II. The common thread that weaves these stories together is the musical talent of the young protagonists and a harmonica monogrammed with a mysterious, M.

Part I is the story of Friedrich, a German schoolboy who is disfigured and has epilepsy. Sadly, his sister has joined the Hitler youth and tries to convince Friedrich to do the same. He fears that is disabilities will cause him to be sent to a prison camp. His only hope is if his musical talent will enable him to be accepted into the musical conservatory.

Part II is the story of two orphans from Pennsylvania who are getting desperate to find a home. They find themselves in the home of a despondent widow who has lost the will to live after much tragedy in her life. Through music, the boys open her heart and give her a reason to live again.

Part III is the story of Ivy, another musical prodigy who, along with her family, is caretaking the home of a Japanese family who has been sent to an internment camp after the bombing of Pearl Harbor. American officials are suspicious that the Japanese family is hiding something in the house. After Ivy discovers a secret room, the officials search the house, only discover that the Yamamotos were hiding musical instruments. “Everyone needs beauty and light in their lives, especially during the worst of times.”

In the end the three stories come together beautifully in a musical finale that touches the heart. Pam Munoz Ryan is a master at telling a story that creates a bond between the reader and the characters. She touches on difficult subjects in a way that is assessable to students.